Opposing budget is only constitutional way to protect public from ‘punitive’ measures, Le Pen says
Marine Le Pen, leader of the far-right National Rally (RN), has said that backing a no-confidence motion to oust Michel Barnier as prime minister is the only constitutional way to protect the French public from a “dangerous, unjust and punitive budget”.
In a post on X, she wrote:
In all the most outlandish and ridiculous explanations heard this morning in the media about the reasons that push us to choose censorship, one is missing.
Precisely, the one and only one that guided our choice: censoring this budget is, unfortunately, the only way the constitution gives us to protect the French from a dangerous, unjust and punitive budget which, moreover, worsens the already monstrous deficits of seven years of Macronism.
Together, the New Popular Front (NFP), a leftwing coalition that includes the Socialists, Greens, and the RN have enough MPs to topple the government. Two no-confidence motions will be put forward, including one by the far right that is unlikely to pass, but with the one proposed by the hard-left set to go through with backing from Le Pen’s RN lawmakers.
Over the weekend, Le Pen demanded that Barnier make further budget concessions to avoid a no confidence motion. Barnier had already dropped a planned electricity tax increase, but the RN also wanted him to raise pensions in line with inflation. Barnier made some concessions but not enough, in the eyes of Le Pen, who accused the former Brexit negotiator of not keeping his promise to listen to political groups opposed to the budget bill.
Key events
Marine Le Pen, leader of the far-right National Rally (RN), has said a motion of censure “is not a coalition or a political agreement” after the leader backed a no-confidence motion to oust Michel Barnier as prime minister.
Le Pen previously said backing the no-confidence motion is the only constitutional way to protect the French public from a “dangerous, unjust and punitive budget”.
On X of Tuesday, she wrote:
Let’s be clear: a motion of censure is not a coalition or a political agreement, it is nothing other than the expression of a disavowal of the policy and budgetary choices proposed by the Government.
Dans des manœuvres d’enfumage et de désinformation, le parti de M. Attal dénonce une supposée collusion entre le Rassemblement national et LFI. Que les choses soient clairement dites : une motion de censure n’est pas une coalition ni un accord politique, elle n’est rien d’autre…
— Marine Le Pen (@MLP_officiel) December 3, 2024
“The only alliance that was formed and that plunged France into chaos was that of the two-round legislative elections, where the Macronists and the far left, hand in hand, withdrew in 210 constituencies to block the National Rally.”
US president-elect Donald Trump will attend the reopening celebration for Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris this weekend, his first foreign trip since winning the election. France and Germany, the EU’s most powerful countries, are in political flux just weeks ahead of the former Republican president re-entering the White House on 20 January. So, what was the relationship like between Emmanuel Macron and Trump during his last term?
During Trump’s first term in office, between 2017 and 2021, Macron proved to be among the world leaders most adept at managing the American president’s whims as he tried to develop a personal connection built in no small part on flattery.
Macron was the guest of honour at Trump’s first state dinner and Trump travelled to France several times. But the relationship soured as Trump’s term progressed and Macron criticised him for questioning the need for Nato and raising doubts about America’s commitment to the mutual-defence pact.
Macron and other European leaders are now trying to persuade Trump not to abandon America’s support for Ukraine in its fight against Russia’s nearly three-year invasion. Trump over the weekend announced that he intends to nominate real estate developer Charles Kushner, the father of his son-in-law, Jared Kushner, to serve as ambassador to France.
You may be wondering where the French president Emmanuel Macron is. He began a three-day state visit to Saudi Arabia on Monday with the stated aim of boosting diplomatic and economic ties. If the no confidence vote in Michel Barnier fails tomorrow, which is looking likely, Macron, whose mandate extends to 2027 whatever happens politically, can restart talks on appointing a new prime minister and forming a new government.
Marine Le Pen, who has the power to decide the fate of the current government, has been embroiled in a high-profile embezzlement trial, which comes almost a decade after initial investigations started. If found guilty on 31 March 2025, the three-time presidential candidate of the far-right National Rally (RN) could be blocked from participating in France’s next presidential election, scheduled for 2027.
Le Pen, her party – which was at the time called the National Front, and others including former lawmakers and parliamentary assistants – are accused of using money destined for work at the European Parliament to pay staff who were actually working for the party.
Le Pen and her co-defendants deny the charges and say the way they used the money was legitimate, and that the allegations are based on a too-narrow definition of what a parliamentary assistant does. “She could hope, if she won, to be in the Elysee Palace by early February – giving the judges an impossible task when they have to decide whether or not to ban her from politics for five years on 31 March,” wrote Mujtaba Rahman, managing director for Europe at Eurasia Group.
If convicted, Le Pen would be able to lodge an appeal. European parliament authorities said the legislature had lost €3m through the jobs scheme. The RN has paid back (at least) €1m, which it says is not an admission of guilt.
Here are some comments, carried by franceinfo, made by French politicians this morning about the looming no confidence vote and the political turbulence the country is experiencing:
The Socialist leader, Olivier Faure, told France’s most-watched news channel, the 24-hour BFMTV:
We have been trying for two months to make proposals to the prime minister, and the only one he has reached out to is Marine Le Pen…
He has acknowledged being a prisoner of his common base and not being able to make any gesture in our direction. If we censor, it is not because we do not like Michel Barnier. We want to achieve progress on the substance, in particular pensions and health.
Charlotte Parmentier-Lecocq, the minister delegate to the minister of solidarity, autonomy and equality (with responsibility for people with disabilities), told Radio J:
I am worried about the impact that the vote on this motion of censure could have, if the left and the RN decide to vote for it, on people with disabilities.
Lucie Castets, who was the leftist New Popular Front (NFP) alliance’s choice for prime minister before Michel Barnier was appointed, has criticised the centre-right government for relying on support from the far-right National Rally for “ideological reasons”, making reference to concessions on “state medical aid”, which she says will cause France to “move away from its principles of humanity”. Over the summer, French President Emmanuel Macron refused to nominate a government led by the NFP, despite it having won the largest number of seats in parliament in elections in July. Macron, seen as a centrist by many, claimed that the left could not win a confidence vote that would likely be triggered from parliamentary opponents. On Tuesday, Castets said:
I was part of the solution in the summer, I made myself available and I prepared to govern with the forces of the New Popular Front and with the forces of civil society who have a lot to contribute.
Opposing budget is only constitutional way to protect public from ‘punitive’ measures, Le Pen says
Marine Le Pen, leader of the far-right National Rally (RN), has said that backing a no-confidence motion to oust Michel Barnier as prime minister is the only constitutional way to protect the French public from a “dangerous, unjust and punitive budget”.
In a post on X, she wrote:
In all the most outlandish and ridiculous explanations heard this morning in the media about the reasons that push us to choose censorship, one is missing.
Precisely, the one and only one that guided our choice: censoring this budget is, unfortunately, the only way the constitution gives us to protect the French from a dangerous, unjust and punitive budget which, moreover, worsens the already monstrous deficits of seven years of Macronism.
Together, the New Popular Front (NFP), a leftwing coalition that includes the Socialists, Greens, and the RN have enough MPs to topple the government. Two no-confidence motions will be put forward, including one by the far right that is unlikely to pass, but with the one proposed by the hard-left set to go through with backing from Le Pen’s RN lawmakers.
Over the weekend, Le Pen demanded that Barnier make further budget concessions to avoid a no confidence motion. Barnier had already dropped a planned electricity tax increase, but the RN also wanted him to raise pensions in line with inflation. Barnier made some concessions but not enough, in the eyes of Le Pen, who accused the former Brexit negotiator of not keeping his promise to listen to political groups opposed to the budget bill.
No-confidence vote will be debated in parliament from 4pm on Wednesday – reports
Angelique Chrisafis
Angelique Chrisafis is the Guardian’s Paris correspondent
French media reported that the parliament discussion of the no-confidence vote would begin on Wednesday at 4pm, with MPs voting in the evening.
If MPs from the far-right and the left alliance all back the no-confidence vote, this means the French government could fall as early as tomorrow night.
Michel Barnier would become the shortest-serving prime minister of France’s Fifth Republic, at only three months in office.
What will happen if Barnier loses the no-confidence vote?
French prime minister Michel Barnier is bracing for a no-confidence vote tomorrow (or possibly Thursday). The high-stakes parliamentary vote could trigger a financial crisis for the eurozone’s second-largest economy and powerful EU member. If Barnier loses the vote, he will likely stay in power in a caretaker capacity while the country’s unpopular president, Emmanuel Macron, tries to find a replacement, but there is a range of other possibilities. Here is a little more detail about what will happen if the government falls (full explainer here):
Barnier has said there could be “serious financial turbulence” if his budget fails to pass and the government falls, and markets have already responded with alarm, with the interest rate on French bonds coming close to that of their Greek counterparts last week.
There is no fear of a US-style shutdown since France’s constitution allows for a government – possibly even a caretaker government – to pass an emergency law in effect prolonging the previous year’s budget for a few months, so public sector workers, for example, continue to be paid.
In terms of France’s governance, if the National Rally (RN) does join forces with the left-leaning New Popular Front (NFP) to bring Barnier down, Macron has a range of choices. But he is constitutionally constrained by the fact that, because he dissolved parliament in June, he cannot do so again until June 2025.
The president could simply reinstate Barnier as prime minister, which parliament would see as provocative and most observers therefore consider unlikely. He could also ask France’s warring political parties to try to build a new coalition, this time with more support.
That could, for example, involve renewed centrist attempts to peel more moderate elements of the NFP, including the PS, away from the leftist bloc. Although the NFP has frequently appeared fractured, there is no guarantee that would work.
Macron could also decide to appoint a technocratic government to oversee France’s administration for another six months. Finally, he could himself resign, triggering new presidential elections, but for the time being that is seen as unlikely.
France at ‘turning point’ as government heads towards collapse
Welcome to our live coverage of the political crisis engulfing France as the country faces the potential downfall of its government.
It is looking almost certain that Michel Barnier, the centre-right prime minister appointed by French President Emmanuel Macron after July’s inconclusive parliamentary election, will lose a no-confidence motion over the budget tomorrow.
Barring a last-minute surprise, his fragile coalition will be the first French government to be forced out by a no-confidence vote since 1962.
Barnier’s budget, which seeks to reduce France’s spiralling public deficit through €60bn ($62.9bn; £49.6bn) in tax hikes and spending cuts, has been opposed by politicians on both the left and far right.
He used special powers to force the belt-tightening social security budget through the lower house of parliament without a final vote after a last-minute concession was not enough to win over far-right the National Rally (RN), led by Marine Le Pen. Barnier’s minority government had relied on RN support for its survival.
The left and the far right combined have enough votes to topple Barnier, and Le Pen confirmed on Monday that her party would vote for the left-wing coalition’s no-confidence bill as well as her own.
France’s finance minister, Antoine Armand, has warned that France is at a critical juncture due to uncertainty over the budget and future composition of the government.
“The country is at a turning point,” Armand told France 2 TV this morning, adding politicians had a responsibility “not to plunge the country into uncertainty” with a no-confidence vote. Barnier is due to address television news programmes around 1900 GMT. We will be providing updates throughout the day.