We still have a lot of time to wait for the upcoming Star Trek series Starfleet Academy, but everything we’ve heard thus far sounds like it’ll be worth it. Robert Picardo took some time away from production to talk about the show in an interview, and I can’t help but wonder about one thing he said about Paul Giamatti.
The cast of Starfleet Academy is loaded with talent, including Oscar nominee and Trekkie Paul Giamatti. Picardo, who will return to Star Trek alongside other veterans of the franchise for the new show, spoke to TVO Today about the show, and made the following comment about the stacked lineup of actors:
We’ve got Holly Hunter, who’s an extraordinary movie star and Oscar-winning actress who is leading our show as the Chancellor of Starfleet [Academy]. The first season villain is Paul Giamatti. And then there’s this incredible cast of new young actors – many of them have credits they’re just new to me. But they’re just really talented and unique, and their characters, both in the writing and their performance, I find very well defined. So I’m excited.
Most people will look at that quote and find it innocent enough. Star Trek fans are a different breed, however, who latch on to the most minor details and speculate about them nonstop.
As such, I couldn’t help but immediately clock Paul Giamatti being referred to as the Season 1 villain and what that could mean for Starfleet Academy. Here are a couple of the thoughts going through my head right now…
Will Paul Giamatti Leave Starfleet Academy After Season 1?
Robert Picardo referring to Paul Giamatti as the Season 1 villain has me wondering if this would mean there will be a new villain in Season 2. If that’s the case, we’d have to assume Giamatti’s character might not be around for future episodes beyond the inaugural season and written off the show.
Paul Giamatti doing Star Trek was a shock, mainly because of how much of an in-demand actor he is in Hollywood. He’s working in television and movies and is fresh off a Best Actor Oscar nomination for his role in the critically acclaimed film The Holdovers.
I guess it’s obvious, in hindsight, that his time in Starfleet Academy may be finite. We should be prepared for other actors, maybe someone like Katee Sackoff, to take his place just in case.
Will Paul Giamatti’s Character No Longer Be A Villain?
Another possibility is that Paul Giamatti will remain with the show but transition out of being a villain. Character shifts like this aren’t new in Star Trek, so I wouldn’t be shocked for it to happen. While described as a villain, we also know that Giamatti’s character has a loose connection to one of the cadets in Starfleet Academy.
My thinking is that while Giamatti may not be around Starfleet Academy quite as much after Season 1, there is always potential for a return via that one cadet character down the stretch. Of course, this could happen when he’s still a villain, but I’d like to think he’d have to change his ways for the Starfleet student to still associate with them.
Whatever the case, I’m still just as stoked to be streaming Starfleet Academy with my Paramount+ subscription when it arrives sometime in early 2026. I hope I’m reading too much into things, and we’ll get way more of Paul Giamatti than I’m currently expecting after this recent interview with Robert Picardo.